Photos of Garrett Bardsley before his disappearance. Photo: The Charley Project
Garret Bardsley was fishing with his dad at Cuberant Lake in Utah, when he decided to return to camp for a change of clothes. Even though the camp was only 250 feet away from the lake Garret never made it back and has never been seen since.
Who was Garret Bardsley?
Garret Bardsley was a 12 year old boy from Summit County, Utah. He was a happy child who loved the outdoors, baseball and wanted to be a missionary when he grew up.
He was described as caucasian, with light brown hair and hazel eyes. At the time he went missing his hair was shoulder length. He had a little gap between his two front teeth and a birthmark on his right forearm.
When he disappeared he was wearing a black hooded sweatshirt from QuickSilver, with the brand name written on it, and it was a size medium.
His pants were reversible Nike sweatpants. On one side, they were red and made of silky fabric, with black and white stripes running down the legs. On the other side, they were made of black mesh and had red and white stripes on the legs.
He also had a white t-shirt on, which may have had some words or a logo on it. He was wearing Nike ankle socks, and his shoes were white Converse sneakers with a black or navy-colored star on the sides. They were sized between six and eight.
The Disappearance of Garret Bardsley
Lake Cuberant where Garrett Bardsley was last seen. Photo: Strange Outdoors
On the morning of August 20, 2004, and 12-year-old Garrett Bardsley and his dad, Kevin, were on a camping trip with a group of Boy Scouts in the Uinta Mountains in Utah.
They woke up early and went to a nearby lake called Cuberant 1 for some fishing. They had been camping since August 19 and planned to leave on August 21.
While fishing, Garrett's shoes, pants, and socks got all wet, and he didn't feel comfortable in them. So, he asked his dad if he could go back to their campsite, located just 150-250 feet away, to change his clothes.
He promised his dad that he would be back soon to try and catch a fish for breakfast. The rest of their Boy Scout group was camped nearby at the Cuberant #4 campsite, up the hill from where Garrett and his dad were fishing.
Kevin had walked the trail with his son several times before, so when Garrett asked if he could go back to camp alone, Kevin didn't think twice about it. He kept an eye on Garrett as he walked around the lake and even shouted directions, making sure Garrett knew which path to take to get back to camp.
But after about 20 minutes, Kevin began to wonder why his son hadn't returned yet. He decided to head back to camp to see what was going on, but when he got there, Garrett was nowhere to be found. None of the other Boy Scouts had seen him return to camp.
The Search for Garret Bardsley
A video telling the story of Garrett Bardsley
The campsite was really close to the lake, less than a quarter-mile away, and there was a well-established path that connected the two places.
A family friend said that the distance from where they were fishing to the camp was no more than 150 paces away. The path also connected to a road about another quarter-mile away.
Despite the short distance, more than 200 volunteers and search and rescue team members searched for Garrett into the night on August 21.
Teams from Utah, Salt Lake, Wasatch, and Duchesne counties were joined by additional search and rescue teams from Cache County to help. Garrett had no backpack or provisions with him. He only had a short, black and chrome ice-fishing pole with him when he disappeared.
After Garrett's disappearance, hundreds of volunteers and personnel from the Summit County Sheriff's Office searched for him on foot, on horseback, and with dogs. However, the effort was eventually scaled back to 50 professional search and rescue personnel who continued to search on foot.
The only evidence that searchers found was one of Garrett's Nike socks, which was discovered half a mile away from where he disappeared in a granite boulder field. Summit County Sheriff Dave Edmunds commented on the sock, saying, "The sock appears that it was taken off of a wet foot, wadded up, very consistent with what we know about Garrett."
Given where the sock was found, Edmunds suggested that Garrett may have sought shelter from the cold weather, possibly by going into the boulder field to find a crevasse or outcropping to protect himself. The mountainous terrain meant that the temperature dropped to around 18 degrees on the night Garrett went missing.
The local police concluded that there was insufficient evidence to suggest that Garrett had been kidnapped. The official search for Garrett lasted nine days and covered a three-mile radius in the rugged mountains from where he was last seen. Despite the extensive search efforts, no significant evidence was found.
After the official search ended, Garrett's family, along with many dedicated friends and volunteers, continued to search for him. They returned to the area at least two or three times each week until October. Further searches were conducted after the winter of 2004, but unfortunately, they did not yield any new clues about Garrett's whereabouts.
Garrett has never been seen since.
Theories about the Disappearance of Garrett Bardsley
Any theories about what may have happened to Garrett Bardsley are pure speculation at this point in time. A number of things are possible:
He was kidnapped
He was murdered by someone at the scout camp
He was attacked and dragged away by a mountain lion
He fell into a crevasse that is too deep for searchers to explore
Some have speculated that Garrett’s disappearance could be connected to other cases of missing people in the wilderness as one of the missing 411.
What do you think might have happened to Garrett Bardsley? Let us know in the comments.
Other Strange Disappearances:
The Disappearance of Vladamir Bastl
The Disappearance of Frederick Valentich
Polish woman Katarzyna Zowada was tortured then skinned alive in 1998 by Robert Janczewski. He then fashioned her skin into a body suit and wore it.
The true story of Barbora Skrlová is almost stranger than fiction. When she was 33 years old Barbora convinced a family that she was a young child and got them to adopt her.
Whispers have circulated online about a town called Doveland in Wisconsin that suddenly disappeared. Is this just another internet hoax or is there something substantial behind the mystery?
Johnny Frank Garret was executed for a crime he claimed he didn’t commit. Within a few years of his death 14 people who had played a part in his conviction were dead. Was this a result of the curse of Johnny Frank Garret?
Henry McCabe, a 31 year old father of two, went missing and was later found dead after sending a strange voicemail to his wife.
Langville, Montana was supposedly a real town in Montana that disappeared at some point before the 2000’s. While all evidence of the town has been wiped from existence some claim the residents were mysteriously “turned inside out” and a cover up has taken place to avoid panic.
In 1996 and 1997 a man named Mike Marcum appeared on Coast to Coast Radio, to talk about his experiments with time travel. A few months later someone he had disappeared and someone called in to Art’s show with a story about a man who was found dead on a California beach in the 1930’s that matched Marcum’s description. Could this be the first documented case of time travel?
The Schooner Jenny was missing for 20 years before the ship was found with the crew frozen solid, standing at attention on the main deck.
Over the last decade, pessimism about the future of humanity seems to have ramped up, particularly in online spaces. Could it be that we instinctively know things are about to change drastically?
The Illuminati card game has become infamous for its uncanny predictions that seem to have come true.
American Mother Riss White has taken to TikTok to tell of how her daughter seems to remember a previous life where she died in the Twin Towers.
The SS Edmund Fitzgerald sank in Lake Superior in 1975 during a storm, resulting in the loss of all 29 crew members. The wreck, discovered at a depth of 530 feet, has yielded minimal recovery of bodies, with only one crew member ever found.
Strange, undecipherable ads appeared in the Daily Wildcat Newspaper every year on the first of may. Several theories exist concerning the origin of the ads but their purpose is yet to be understood.
In London, a woman without any previous mental health issues heard voices in her head while reading at home. The voices reassured her, saying not to be afraid and expressing a desire to help. Worried about her sanity, she sought medical assistance. A psychiatrist, Mr. Ikechukwu Azuonye, documented her case in the British Medical Journal.
Many people who have used the drug DMT report seeing Machine Elves during their trips. Could these creatures be real and, if not, why do so many report seeing the same hallucination?
The 'Little Red Man of Destiny' gained widespread recognition as a bringer of misfortune and calamity throughout France, making appearances to some of the country's most prominent figures for over 260 years.
A newspaper article from 1936 reported that a dying man, after seeing himself in a hand mirror, somehow caused it to be fused with the table it was placed on. No one was able to lift the mirror after the man’s death until it was removed violently with an ice pick.
Katherine Hobbs was convinced she wouldn’t live to 16 years old. She had several premonitions throughout her life that led her to believe she would die young. Katherine lived to be 16 years, three months and three days old.
Slime Mold is a strange single celled organism that has baffled scientists for decades. It can solve mazes, communicate with other slime molds and repair itself in minutes.
In 1936 a teenage girl witnessed a man using a jetpack, flying in the sky above her. Was this event extraterrestrial, a time slip or evidence of secret military technology?
Before the police went to Chris Benoit's house and found him and his family dead, someone made changes to the Wikipedia page about him. These changes were made anonymously and talked about the death of his wife, Nancy Benoit.
On May 13, 1848, a strong earthquake struck Chantibun in eastern Siam (now Thailand). Strangely, human-like hairs emerged from the ground in various locations during the quake, including bazaars, roads, fields, and even solid areas.
The Eltanin Antenna is a strange antenna like structure spotted on the ocean floor at a depth of 12,808 ft by a research ship in 1964. Some believe it may be an extraterrestrial artifact.
The Gate of the Gods is an ancient structure in Peru with mysterious origins. No one knows who built it or why.
A four-mile stretch of Missouri-Pacific railroad is home to a strange ball of light that has been sighted hundreds, if not thousands of times. What is not known is what the Gurdon Light is and what causes it.
A caulbearer is a baby born with a “veil” covering its face made from an unbroken amniotic sac. It is said that a child born this way will grow up to have unique paranormal protections or even psychic abilities.
On the 25th November 1972 Captain John Gray returned to his bunk aboard the SS Great Britain complaining of stomach pain. He was never seen again.
Nestled within the breathtaking landscapes of Alaska lies a mysterious and foreboding place known as the Alaska Triangle, where people and planes vanish without a trace, and unexplainable phenomena abound.
Soldiers stationed at OP Rock have witnessed bizarre occurrences: eerie lights, chilling static on the radio, fluctuating temperatures, and haunting whispers in the night, accompanied by an unexplained stench of death.
In 1775, a ghost ship named Octavius was discovered stranded off the coast of Greenland, with the frozen remains of all 28 crew members found below deck.
The Hathor Temple is an ancient Egyptian temple located within the Dendera Temple complex in Egypt. Strangely, some of the temples solid granite stairs appear to have melted.
The Sky Stone, a striking bluish rock, is thought to be a piece of a meteorite that fell to Earth. This unique stone was found in Africa and is said to contain a high concentration of oxygen.
In August 1942, the L-8 came back from its patrol of the California coast to search for Japanese submarines, but its two-person crew was no where to be seen.
On the evening of the 18th April 2023, a strange pillar of light has been seen by hundreds of people in the sky over Detroit. What is going on?
Chaneque are legendary creatures from Mexican folklore that are said to look like children with the face of an old person.
Some researchers believe that an archaeological site unearthed in Tennessee may have been created by ancient Egyptians.
In 1983, Loren Coleman coined the term "Bridgewater Triangle" to refer to an area located between Abington, Rehoboth, and Freetown in Massachusetts. This area seems to be a focal point for strange phenomena in the United States.
The "third man factor" is when someone in a dangerous or high-stress situation hears a voice giving them encouragement or advice. This voice is seen as coming from a spiritual or supernatural source, not just their own thoughts.